Customer Reviews

Read what some of our satisfied insurance customers have to say! If you’d like to provide your feedback, please submit your online review.

  • JW

    “Walked in, got great rates, much cheaper then I was paying in years. Had 2 minor accidents since we changed insurance and they have been very helpful with both claims. ”

  • ML

    “Justin Schaeffer has been wonderful to work with. He helped us set-up a new auto policy, as well as a homeowner’s policy. Being able to do everything electronically was awesome. Thank you so much! We look forward to many years with you. ”

  • BN

    “Great services and reasonable rates!

  • LR

    “All of my needs are always met and in a timely matter when dealing with Schaeffer Insurance. The office staff is wonderful! I have never had a problem and I have been a customer of Schaeffer for at least 30 years.”

  • NG

    “The staff is always helpful and friendly.”

  • BZ

    “I’ve gotten the best rates here. Better than anywhere.

  • C

    “They are awesome !
    Every time l call if l need something
    It’s done right away .”

  • AS

    “Schaeffer Insurance is always attentive to my needs an answers all my questions promptly. Been a customer since my early 20’s an I’m now in my late 40’s.”

  • NP

    “You and the people at the office were wonderful I felt comfortable and I felt like it was a family & the agent made sure I understood what kind of policy I had purchased before I signed and I was also recommended by a friend who feels the same way”

  • MB

    “They are awesome !
    Every time l call if l need something
    It’s done right away .

  • “They are very helpful in finding the insurance you need.

  • DE

    “I loved the prompt response to my website inquire and you explained the policies.”

  • LE

    “Erie been my insurance Co. For years. Auto, home, and business. Carmela and John have always responded immediately with any of my concerns, questions or insurance needs.
    AAA class service.

  • KN

    “I have used Schaffer’s Insurance for 25 plus years…

    They have always come to our rescue in times of need. When Hurricane Floyd hit in 1999 we lived on 4 acres and had extensive damage and Schaffer’s Insurance was there for us, no questions asked if it was damaged it was repaired or replaced.

    Later after we retired we moved into a condo. The upstairs neighbor’s water pipe broke..Schaffer’s guided us and the insurance paid for all personal property ruined by the busted pipe water.

    We have had many different cars insured and were always pleased with the service.

    And sadly when my husband passed Schaffer’s was there for me. We has life insurance. So through all the times when things were low, Schaffer’s was there to lend a hand and guide us through an adversary.

    Thank you, Duane and Justin, for the help you have given me through the years.”

  • KN

    “I have used Schaeffer Insurance for 25 plus years..

    They have always come to our rescue in times of need. When Hurricane Floyd hit in 1999 we lived on 4 acres and had extensive damage and Schaffer’s Insurance was there for us, no questions asked, if it was damaged it was repaired or replaced.

    Later after we retired we moved into a condo. The upstairs neighbor’s water pipe broke..Schaffer’s guided us and the insurance paid for all personal property ruined by the busted pipe water.

    We have had many different cars insured and were always pleased with the service.

    And sadly when my husband passed Schaffer’s was there for me. We has life insurance. So through all the times when things were low, Schaffer’s was there to lend a hand and guide us through adversary.

    Thank you Duane and Justin for the help you have given me through the years.”